It’s always surprising to be caught out by an assumption.
In this case I was writing a first draft of a paper on the effects of rank change (that is, change in organic maturation) on a coalbed methane reservoir. The study area, known locally as the Pinang Dome, is located in Kalimantan (Borneo), Indonesia. As I was writing the Introduction to the paper I casually made a statement about its well-known rank trends and put within parentheses “REF”, denoting I would have to look up those references later.
Unfortunately, when I did look up those references I found exactly – none! None that is which showed actual data of any kind that might demonstrate an increase, or even a lack of increase, in rank. No doubt there are probably reports out there that have these data, but they lie beyond my reach.
Thus, as a side project to the paper being written, I decided to write an additional short paper (along with my co-author Chairul Nas) on what exactly is known and verifiable, about rank changes around the Pinang Dome and present it at the Indonesian Petroleum Association Conference in Jakarta in May 2013*. The presentation can be downloaded from this link: TAMoore 2013 IPA talk.pptx
After a bit of data mining, our basic conclusions were that:
- Coal rank does increase towards the southwest side of the Pinang Dome but is not concentric around the dome as might be expected (and previously assumed),
- The geothermal gradient is higher in the south and southwest side of the Pinang Dome (50ºC/km) compared with the regional geothermal gradient (27º to 39ºC/km),
- A Bouguer gravity anomaly survey does indicate higher density rock in the subsurface beneath the Pinang Dome, compared with the surrounding rock; the highest density rock appears in to be in the vicinity of the south-western side of the dome. This data favors more dense igneous rock being present underlying (or near proximity to) the dome.
On balance, the data seems to favor an igneous diapir as the origin of the Pinang Dome, though this is by no means, as yet, conclusive with the available data set. There may be additional data that can shed light on the origin of the Pinang Dome, though these data may be typically difficult, for this part of the world, to obtain. Future programs of exploration should strive to collect robust data on both temperature and rank changes down hole, which will help unlock organic and coal rank trends in this region of Kalimantan.
The presentation must have been convincing, as I was fortunate to be awarded the ‘Best Overall Paper’ for the conference. As there are over 4000 people registered for 150 or so talks, I am deeply honored to have received this distinction and my best regards and thanks go the committee.
*Moore, T.A., and Nas, C., 2013. The enigma of the Pinang Dome (Kalimantan Timur): A review of its origin, significance and influence on coal rank and coalbed methane properties. Proceedings, Indonesian Petroleum Association, 37th Annual Convention & Exhibition, May 15-17, Jakarta, Indonesia, Paper IPA13-G-119, not paginated